RarePeerRarePeerby Matchtern
Log inSign up
VoteLeaderboardResultsForum
🗳️Vote🏆Board📋Results💬Forum
Privacy·Terms·Report a bug or suggest a feature
Active community

Discussion

Real talk on admissions, extracurriculars, awards, competitions, research, and getting into top universities. Moderated. No toxicity, no spam.

💡 How this works

Your school doesn't get attached to your posts unless you put it there yourself. Want to post anonymously? Tag your post #rejection. That's the only tag that unlocks anonymous posting.

Log in to start a thread or reply
12
S11th · STEM· 11d ago
junior bay area magnet, chance me MIT/Stanford/CMU/Caltech CS+math
Demographics: - male, korean - CA, public magnet - full pay - no hooks Intended Major: Math + CS (joint or double) Academics: - GPA: 4.0 UW / 4.7 W - Rank: school doesn't rank, ~top 5% based on prior years - SAT: 1570 (800M / 770V) - Coursework: 10 APs by junior year, all 5s. Multivariable + linalg this year, planning grad real analysis next year through dual enrollment. ECs: - USAMO qualifier sophomore + junior, gunning MOP this summer - AIME 12 / USAMO 28 last cycle - MIT Primes-USA, working with a postdoc on combinatorial geometry, paper in review - Math team captain, school placed top 3 ARML last year - Run a free CS bootcamp for middle schoolers on weekends, wrote the curriculum Awards: - USAMO honors - AMC 12 perfect score (junior) - 2x AIME qualifier Schools (working list, not final): Reach: - MIT - Caltech - Stanford - Princeton Match: - CMU SCS - Berkeley EECS - Harvey Mudd Safety: - UCSD - UCSB CCS at my school this is middle of the pack tbh. half the math team has Primes or RSI. is the MOP push enough to differentiate or do i need a different angle. be honest
#chanceme#academics#extracurriculars#11th-grade💬 0 replies
8
I12th · Business· 11d ago
T10 business results, going Wharton
Demographics: - Black female - IL - top private prep school - upper income, applied need-blind Academics: - GPA: 3.94 UW / 4.5 W - SAT: 1520 - 11 APs, mostly 5s ECs: - Varsity track captain, state finalist 400m - DECA ICDC qualifier 2x, top 10 in Principles of Finance - Founded a financial literacy nonprofit for South Side high schoolers, ran summer workshops 3 years - IB externship through a Goldman HCM connection summer after junior - Model UN traveling team Awards: - DECA ICDC top 10 - IL state track finalist - AP Scholar with Distinction Acceptances: - Wharton (ED, committing) - NYU Stern - Ross BBA - McIntire (OOS) - USC Marshall (with merit) - Indiana Kelley direct admit Waitlists: - MIT Sloan - Cornell Dyson Rejections: - none, ED locked it before RD Going to: Wharton. applying M&T sophomore year if i can swing the CS prereqs. Reflection: the Goldman HCM line is what made the externship section real on my app. that does not happen without my mom's coworker pulling strings, i should say that out loud. essays were about specific moments running the nonprofit workshops, not the founding story. counselor wanted me to lead with track and i'm glad i didn't. happy to answer Wharton vs Stern vs Ross questions if anyone's deciding RD.
#collegeresults#applications#12th-grade💬 0 replies
5
P11th · STEM· 11d ago
tactical guide: cold-emailing professors as a HS junior (took me 6 weeks to get a yes)
i see this question every week so i'm writing the post i wish i'd read. junior, ISEF finalist, second author on a paper published through a local university lab. here is literally what worked for me. The email itself: - Subject line should name the specific paper you read. NOT "high school student looking for research opportunity". mine was "question about your 2024 paper on X in [journal]". that one got opened. - Two paragraphs max. first paragraph: who you are in one sentence, then the paper you read and one concrete question or extension you thought about. second paragraph: what you can offer (hours per week, summer availability, lab safety training if you have it). attach a one-page CV. - Send tuesday through thursday morning. mondays die in triage and fridays disappear into the weekend. Who to email: - Read 2-3 papers from their group before you write. find the ones where there's a clear next step. PIs notice when you've actually read the paper, genuinely. - Email grad students and postdocs too, not just full profs. 60% of my replies came from postdocs who then looped in their PI. they need help, they're closer to your timeline, and they remember being a HS student trying to break in. - Local R1 universities first. you cannot help a lab you cannot get to. unless you have a real funded summer program lined up (SIMR, SSP, RSI), in-person at the local university beats remote at the famous lab every time. The numbers, for honesty: - 34 emails over 6 weeks - 4 replies, 2 said no, 1 said spring, 1 said yes - The yes was the postdoc, not the PI. she ran the day-to-day, PI signed off after a 15 min zoom. What did not work: - Mass-emailing 50 profs the same template. they can tell. - Saying "interested in your work" without naming the work. zero responses on those. - Asking about "any opportunities". be specific about the project or paper you want to extend. persistence with a bad email is just spam at higher volume. spend the time on the first 10, get the language right, then scale. dm if you want a second pair of eyes on your template, the above is 90% of what i'd tell you anyway.
#research#extracurriculars#11th-grade💬 0 replies
9
J12th · Humanities· 33d ago
Yale + Princeton + Stanford humanities essays, same pitch or differentiate
Question for anyone applying T10 humanities. I've been writing my main essays around the same intellectual through-line (constitutional philosophy, specifically how the Federalist Papers handle minority rights). It's a strong angle for me. Mock trial nationals, dad's a constitutional litigator, I've been reading this stuff since middle school. Problem: applying Yale (Directed Studies pitch), Princeton (SPIA vs A.B. Politics), and Stanford. Wondering if I should: A. Keep the same intellectual core for all three and let each school's culture shape the framing (Yale = Directed Studies grounded, Princeton = SPIA practical policy, Stanford = interdisciplinary tech-policy crossover). B. Write three substantively different essays with different angles so AOs at each school don't wonder if I'm copy-pasting. My counselor says A. A private consultant my dad knows says B. Lol I genuinely don't know who to listen to. For Yale, Directed Studies is the program I'd actually pick a degree around, so the essay is honest. For Princeton SPIA, the same core lands but the framing has to be more practical-policy. Stanford is the harder one. They don't have a humanities program of the same intensity, and the public policy angle is less of a thing there. Applying RD next week. A or B?
#essays#applications#12th-grade💬 2 replies
7
S12th · STEM· 33d ago
chance me applied math, public exam school, looking at MIT / Caltech / Princeton
Demographics: - female - NYC public exam school (Stuyvesant) - middle income - no hooks Intended major: Applied Math + Econ double, Wharton M&T as the cross-admit dream Academics: - GPA: 3.97 UW / 4.62 W - SAT: 1560 - 12 APs through senior fall (Calc BC 5, Stats 5, Macro 5, Micro 5) ECs: - AIME qualifier 2x, AMC 12 distinguished honor roll - Stuy math team, ARML team representative - Tutoring at the Stuy peer-tutoring center, ~100 hours over two years - Internship at a Manhattan quant fund summer between junior and senior year (data analysis intern, real desk exposure) - Stuy econ club, organized two industry speaker events Awards: - AIME qualifier 2x - NYS Math League individual all-state - AP Scholar with Distinction - Stuy faculty math award (junior year) Schools: Reach: - MIT - Caltech - Princeton (ORFE) - Harvard - Penn (Wharton M&T as the absolute dream cross-admit) Match: - Cornell - UMich - Northwestern (MMSS) - UC Berkeley Safety: - Stony Brook - Binghamton - CUNY Macaulay am i out of my mind for putting MIT and Caltech both as reaches when AIME is the strongest thing on my app. is that enough or do i need to lean harder on the quant internship in essays. be honest
#chanceme#applications#12th-grade💬 3 replies

9+ more posts this week

See every chanceme, results thread, and essay drop.

Sign up free to read the rest of the feed and join the discussion. 30 seconds, no email confirmation.

Sign up freeLog in
12
R12th · STEM· 34d ago
BS-MD interview prep, what actually came up in your PLME / GAP / HPME interview
Asking the hivemind because the BS-MD interview cycle is starting and the prep guides online are vague. Context: Indian-American male, NJ, applying Brown PLME, Pittsburgh GAP, Northwestern HPME, Rice/Baylor. Interviewed at GAP last week. PLME virtual scheduled in two weeks. What I saw at GAP: - "Why medicine" (stock, expected) - "Why this BS-MD specifically vs traditional pre-med" - "Tell me about your research" (I got grilled on the methodology, not just the result) - A behavioral one ("describe a time you disagreed with a mentor") which I wasn't expecting - One ethics question about end-of-life care that felt like an MMI lite Questions I'd love takes on: 1. How technical did the research questions get for you? My PI was an MD-PhD and they asked stuff like "why FACS over IF for that step" which I wasn't prepped for at the BS-MD stage. 2. Did anyone get the "what if you change your mind about medicine" question? Best framing for it. 3. Do they actually expect you to know specific faculty / labs you'd want to work with as an undergrad? I've been told yes but feels insane to commit at 17. Tbh I'll share what I learn after PLME if useful. Drop your war stories.
#applications#research#12th-grade💬 4 replies
8
M11th · STEM· 34d ago
chance me, pre-med + BS-MD applicant going into senior year
Demographics: - female - CA (Bay Area) - top public STEM-focused HS - middle income (no need-based aid eligibility but not full pay either) - no hooks Intended Major: Biology, applying BS-MD programs Academics: - GPA: 3.96 UW / 4.55 W - SAT: 1540 - 11 APs through senior year (Bio 5, Chem 5, Calc BC 5, Lang 4) ECs: - USABO Semifinalist 2x - SUMaC summer after sophomore year - Research at Stanford School of Medicine on tumor immunology, second author on a poster - Hospital volunteer at UCSF Benioff Children's, ~180 hours - Captain of HOSA chapter at school, state finalist in medical innovation Awards: - USABO Semifinalist 2x - HOSA state finalist - AP Scholar with Distinction Schools: Reach (BS-MD): - Brown PLME - Northwestern HPME - Pittsburgh GAP Reach (traditional): - Stanford - Penn - JHU Match: - UCLA - UC Berkeley - Cornell Safety: - UC Davis - UC San Diego PLME is the dream, ngl. Interview prep is what I'm focused on now. Anyone done a PLME or GAP interview? What should I be thinking about beyond "why medicine" and "why BS-MD"?
#chanceme#applications#11th-grade💬 1 replies
10
C12th · Humanities· 34d ago
Yale ED admit, sharing my app + reflection
Demographics: - White female - New England boarding school (Andover/Exeter/Choate-tier) - Greenwich CT family - Legacy (third-gen Yale, dad's side) Intended Major: History + Political Philosophy Academics: - GPA: 4.5/5.0 on the school 5-point scale, A+ caps - SAT: 1530 - 11 APs through senior fall ECs: - Editor-in-chief, school newspaper - Varsity squash, captain senior year (NEPSAC tournament qualifier) - TASS (Telluride Association Summer Seminar) summer between junior and senior year - Founded a debate-and-discussion club around political philosophy, ~30 active members Awards: - Cum Laude Society (junior year) - TASS Telluride Scholar - NEPSAC squash all-academic team Acceptances: - Yale (ED, intended Directed Studies) Going to: Yale. Directed Studies is the freshman seminar program I built half my essays around. Happy to talk about that pitch if anyone's writing a Yale supp now. Reflection: I won't pretend the legacy didn't matter. It did. But the essays did the heavier lifting than I expected, especially the Yale supp where I wrote about something specific (the John Witt civil war legal history seminar I sat in on visiting last summer). Dad pushed me toward the legacy interview but the core of the app was mine. Happy to read essays for anyone working on history / poli sci supps.
#collegeresults#applications#12th-grade💬 5 replies
12
E12th · STEM· 34d ago
is my common app essay topic too cliche
okay so i KNOW essay about my dad's restaurant has been done a million times but it's the most honest thing i can write and i don't want to make up a fake spike just to seem unique. the actual story isn't even about being a 'first-gen kid in america' or 'learning resilience from watching my family work hard'. it's about the lunch rush specifically, like watching my mom triage 18 tickets while my dad is on the phone with the linen guy and i'm bussing tables before going to volleyball practice. the chaos is the essay. the lesson, if there is one, is about how good i've gotten at noticing what's about to break before it breaks. which is honestly how i think about academics too. am i cooked or is this fine. genuinely don't know if AOs see 'restaurant kid' and roll their eyes. applying mostly t30 + a couple reaches
#essays#applications#12th-grade💬 3 replies
6
I12th · Business· 35d ago
Wharton it is. b-school results from a Black female finance kid
Demographics: - Black female - IL - top private prep - upper-middle income - no hooks (legacy doesn't apply) Intended major: Finance + Management double, M&T track if I can lateral Academics: - GPA: 3.97 UW / 4.62 W - ACT: 35 - Coursework: 11 APs, 5s except Lit (4) ECs: - Varsity track captain, state finalist - DECA ICDC qualifier 2x (Marketing Cluster) - Founded Black girls in finance mentoring chapter, ran it 2 years, partnered with the local Goldman Sachs office for resume workshops - Summer internship at a Chicago boutique IB the summer before senior year (real deal flow exposure, not coffee runs) - Church youth leadership board Awards: - National Achievement Scholar - DECA ICDC qualifier - AP Scholar with Distinction - Coca-Cola Scholar semifinalist Acceptances: - Wharton (RD) - NYU Stern - UMich Ross (PSP) - Tuck (early action / non-binding) - UVA McIntire - USC Marshall Waitlists: - Stanford (yield-protected for early commit, didn't bother with the LOCI) Rejections: - Harvard (REA) Going to: Wharton. The M&T lateral is the dream but even baseline Wharton + the Goldman / McKinsey / Bain pipelines are the reason. Ross PSP was a real conversation but Wharton finance recruiting is a different planet. Reflection: i'm gonna be honest, the brand matters. apply to the best b-school you can get into, then optimize for the recruiting pipeline that lines up with what you actually want. essays were the difference for me, especially the Wharton 'community' one, happy to dm anyone working on it.
#collegeresults#applications#12th-grade💬 4 replies
3
D12th · STEM· 35d ago
Harvard rejected me, Rice is paying me to go. FGLI pre-med results
Demographics: - Hispanic male - TX - FGLI - single-parent household - public HS Intended Major: Biology (pre-med) Academics: - GPA: 3.95 UW / 4.7 W - SAT: 1490 - Coursework: 11 APs ECs: - Worked at a local restaurant 20 hrs/wk all four years (mostly closed shifts) - Founded a tutoring program for ESL students at my church, 30+ regular kids - Volunteer at a community clinic, ~250 hours - Captain of the Spanish honor society - Mock trial regional finalist Awards: - QuestBridge finalist - RaiseMe scholarship - AP Scholar with Distinction Acceptances: - Rice (Trustee Distinguished Scholarship, full-tuition + stipend) - Vanderbilt (Cornelius Vanderbilt Scholarship, full-tuition) - UT Austin (Plan II Honors + Forty Acres Scholar) - Texas A&M - UTSA - Trinity University Waitlists: - Yale - Stanford Rejections: - Harvard (REA) - MIT - Princeton Going to: Rice. Visited last weekend and it just felt right. The residential college system reminded me of how my family does Sunday dinner, can't explain it better than that. Reflection: Spent way too much time chasing HYP, cried for a day after Harvard, but honestly Rice is the dream and I don't know why I needed the rejection to see it. Essays carried me, especially the Common App about my mom. Happy to share if anyone wants to read it.
#collegeresults#applications#12th-grade💬 4 replies
12
P11th · STEM· 35d ago
cold-emailing professors as a junior, what actually worked for you
Sharing this since cold-emailing is the question I had no answer to as a sophomore and figuring it out took forever. paying it forward, also genuinely curious what's worked for other people. Quick context: I started cold-emailing in October of my sophomore year, about 35 emails over six months, ended up with two professors who took me on. One I'm still working with. So a 6% hit rate roughly, which I read elsewhere is pretty normal. What I think mattered: 1. Subject line. Not 'high school student looking for research opportunity.' Mine was always something like 'Question about your 2024 paper on [specific topic].' Gets opened. 2. First sentence references their actual work, not a general 'I'm interested in your field.' If you can't name a specific paper, you haven't done enough homework to email them yet. 3. Attach a one-page CV. Not three pages. Profs scan, they don't read. 4. Don't say 'I'll do anything for free.' It sounds desperate and also kind of devalues your time. 5. Follow up exactly once after two weeks. Then move on. What didn't work for me: - Emailing big-name professors at HYPSM. Almost zero replies. - Emailing too many people at the same lab. They talk to each other. - Vague 'any opportunity' emails. anyone have better luck going through grad students or postdocs instead of going straight to PIs?
#research#summer#11th-grade💬 2 replies

📈 Trending tags

💡 How this works

Your school doesn't get attached to your posts unless you put it there yourself. Want to post anonymously? Tag your post #rejection. That's the only tag that unlocks anonymous posting.